Should you tell your spouse EVERYTHING?

I bet a lot of people who are newly married have this question in their mind. Because I did too. You might notice I use past tense because I have found the answer, thus I am no longer questioning.

But for those who are questioning about the answer…. let me start a (quite) long post.

Like usual, let me give a cute GIF to start the post!

Let me tell you a story first about my conversation with my mom that happened long time ago. It was when I was 15 or 16 years old and I didn’t have many relationship experiences, most of my experiences were bad, in a way that I was mostly hurt.

My mom and I were not close, however on that particular day, she decided to have a little talk about relationship and marriage. She said, “when you get married someday, keep some of your secrets for yourself. Don’t share EVERYTHING to your husband. Always keep some secret.” She even emphasized the word don’t share everything. She even said it twice.

Do you think I agreed with her?

Answer is so obvious!

If you know me well, you would know by now that I never agree with my mom about everything. LOL.

I didn’t agree with her on that very moment, but I knew I didn’t have any arguments to defend myself so I chose to shut my big mouth up.

Now that I’m married (tough luck, eh, Mom? LOL) I still disagree with her. But I don’t think she’s wrong.

I don’t think it is wrong not to share everything with your spouse.

But I know for a fact that for me it’s not gonna work. If I didn’t share everything with my spouse, my marriage would fail. That’s me.

So, let’s come back to present moment. I am happily married for 8 months now. I’ve been living together with my husband for 4 years and been together for almost 9 years now.

I do tell my husband EVERYTHING. Seriously, EVERYTHING. So to you, my good friends, when you told me “Don’t tell Bandi!” after you told your story… I never promised. If it was a very secretive thing and I did promise, there is a very small chance I didn’t tell Bandi. (But if someday Bandi asked about it, I would tell him in a heartbeat.)

The thing is…

I’m not good with secrets. Secrets tend to be tied with lies and I am a TERRIBLE LIAR. Seriously I prefer to do anything other than lying. Lying is like a snowball. Once you lie, you have to cover your lies and so on and so on. (I don’t have spare rooms in my brain for this kind of thing!)

Not enough brain cells to lie.

The biggest lie in my life is probably when I live together with Bandi. We have to cover the situation to some people and it was THE WORST! I hated it so much so in some point, I decided to just tell my parents that I lived together with Bandi. There, out of the chest.

For you, male population, who read this, you’re probably wondering how stupid I am, that I am so delusional and I might not know that my husband actually doesn’t do the same thing, which he is NOT telling me everything.

Well… Truth be told, what I’m saying is purely from my side of coin. Yes, I won’t know the fact if Bandi did the same thing to me. But dear… if you don’t trust your spouse, you might as well call a lawyer now and get divorced. Marriage won’t work without trust. This one, I’m 100% sure.

So, I trust him. I trust Bandi is also telling me EVERYTHING.

Bottom line, we tell each other everything. We always thought that healthy relationships have the same thing with us, that the couples tell each other everything, until one day… we found out that it was not the case.

I found out that very moment that the husband lied to the wife about something, even though from my personal opinion, the lie wasn’t even that important! It was a silly lie but he lied anyway and he insisted us not to tell his wife.

Eh, wait! Blackmail idea!

But then after a long conversation with Bandi, we realize that… There is not such thing as a rule of thumb for a perfect relationship. Everyone can design their own relationship and feel perfect about it.

I was so judgy I didn’t know maybe he was protecting her feelings, maybe he knew it better that his wife was better off with lies.

So, let’s go back to the question that made you guys click this blog at the first place. So…


The answer is Yes and No.

It goes back to the purpose of your marriage. This is something that you should discuss with your spouse before you actually got married. So let me put on Dr. Phil mask and do some analytic.

Yes, if you…

  • Are the type of person that value honesty and openness.
  • Are better hurt knowing the truth than not knowing at all.
  • Think it’s about the journey, not the destination.
  • Are a risk taker.

No, if you…

  • Are a goal oriented person.
  • Think ignorance is a bliss.
  • Are practical.
  • Are the type of person that value pride and privacy.
  • Are easily insecure.

So, at the end of the day, it goes back to what type of person you are and what kind of relationship you want. Both are perfectly fine. I have only one thing to underline here… if you have doubts with your spouse, ASK. Never assume. Assuming is the most stupid thing you do in marriage.

When you ask, always believe what your spouse tell you. That’s just how it works.

If you don’t trust your spouse, again, please seek professional help. Something is very wrong.

I hope this post clears any doubts because Valentine’s day is coming!!! I love Valentine’s day! It’s a one-day pass to be mushy mushy in social media! :D

>> What’s your Valentine’s day plan?! Let me know! I love sweet stories!<<


May, assisting Dr. Phil. :p

26 thoughts on “Should you tell your spouse EVERYTHING?

  1. Kalo gw si prinsipnya simple… Apa yang gw tau ya gw kasi tau ke kui, seburuk apapun keadaan itu… Dulu awal2 gw suka assume2, tapi sekarang big NO… Kadang apa yg gw assume tu belom tentu bener…

    My valentine day? Will be on ams may… yey… finally berangkat juga… :p

  2. Gw sama Ai juga sudah saling terbuka dari awal pacaran May. Apaaa aja diceritain..Haha.. Lah gw kagak ditanya aja cerita yak..ahaha :D

    Valentine? Owhhh.. Jelas lah dinner yakk.. Gw juga sukaaa Valentine May..hihih :D Tp bakal late dinner, secara ada sahabat merit tgl itu.. Awww.. Makin sweet gak sih :)

  3. Iya dong gak ada rahasia rahasiaan. Pasti bakal kacau kalau udh mulai ada yg main rahasia sama pasangannya…

    I think one of the most important foundation in relationship is trust and honesty.

  4. Aku setuju kalo kita cerita sama suami daripada sama orang luar . Kalo aku kayaknya bakal nyrocos aja gak perduli ntar suami ku dengerin apa enggak pokoknya kasitau aja deh bahkan kalo gak ditanya juga hahaha

  5. Gw sama kaya lo may! Hidup gw bs ga tenang kalo ada yg belom gw ceritain ke utin. Apapun harus gw ceritain, kl ga bisa ada yg ngeganjel hahaha. Trus gw jg sm ky lo ga bs bohong, keburu pusing dluan musti mikir bohong apaan hahaha.
    Dan gw jg sm ky lo, rahasia2 yg diceritain ke gw sbagian besar jg gw critain ke utin wkakwk. Kecuali yg gw udah lupa hahaha.

    • OK fix, dea! Gw ga mao curhat lagi sama lo!!! LOL. Gw terbuka tentang semua hal sampe yang jorok-jorok sekalipun :p Tapi kalo curhatan orang, gw berusaha banget ga keceplosan. Walaupun gw tau Benny ga bakal ember, buat gw itu bentuk usaha gw menjaga dan menghargai kepercayaan yang udah mereka kasih aja sih. No offense to you two…itu pilihan aja :p

  6. Well… may… i am kind of people that always forget everything, especially gossip (so if you tell me don’t tell anyone and it’s not important or just a gossip i will forget about it immediately)… but if i remember i will tell ridson… or someday when i remember it, i will.
    I really don’t care if ridson tell everything to me or not… but i believe he’s an honest man. He will tell me if it’s important… but he doesn’t like gossip sooo…he will not tell or ever try to remember if it’s just gossip. Both of us r the same i guess…lol.

  7. A very positive and very wise post, May. Personally I guess we all have to deal with the shining principle of openness and honesty on one side and the messiness of daily life on the other. Yes, never betray, never cheat and never lie but don’t cross the limits of one’s partner’s resilience either. So, I guess I might occasionally go for a compromise and just hope I’m not too insecure and don’t favour ignorance in the stride :)

  8. it’s both yes and no for me! of course yes on most of things, but when it comes to a friend’s story she/he shared with me it depends on wether my partner later would need to know or not…? I think there would be times when there would be some things I need and need not to tell him hehe :D

  9. kalo pertanyaannya: SHOULD I TELL MY SPOUSE EVERYTHING? jawabannya no. sbab menurut gw ga perlu semua hal yg terlintas di pikiran gw mesti gw ceritain ke dia. Misalnya hal2 yg berbau komplen (ah valentinan gw ga dikasi bunga, ah si B enak banged bisa jalan2 kluar negri mulu, ah napa sih hari ini misua mukanya jutek pisan?). Buat misua gw yg orangnya sensitip, klo gw ngomong smua bisa2 mala bikin buruk suasana. Lebi baek diem aja dan ngomongnya klo pas suasana lagi bagus. Smakin hidup lama dengan seseorang kan kita pasti liat banyak kekurangannya donk, tapi klo tiap saat kita komplen kurang2nya dia, siapa sih yg seneng? pasti kesel donk. Jadi yah jaga perasaan masing2 lah. Tapi klo gosip2 ga penting si mostly gw cerita :P

    Tapi klo pertanyaannya: SHOULD MY SPOUSE TELL ME EVERYTHING? jawabannya yesss hahaha *curang*. yg jelas gw bukan orang sensitip, jadi misal misua bilang: ‘eh si A (cewe) tuh badannya bagus ya’, gw ga akan jeolous lantas merasa insecure (trs gw juga ga akan mendadak rajin gym supaya badan gw ga kalah bagus), gw still hepi2 aja hihihi (karena gw org cuek), so I think it depends on your spouse characteristic :)

    btw dapet dr mana sih gambar2 gif gitu? lucuuu!

  10. Sometimes I didn’t tell my girlfriend everything because if she know, she will be upset…like the thing what I’ve done with my ex-girlfriends etc…in some condition, ignorance is a bliss. But if she ever ask me about it, I would tell her the truth in a heartbeat. So, I won’t tell her everything, but I won’t lie. What do you think about this, May?

Leave a Reply to MiaMichaelaa Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s